Finding the right holster for your 1911 Commander can be a real challenge. It needs to be comfortable, secure, and, let’s be honest, look good too. A good leather holster offers that classic look and feel, but with so many options out there, it’s tough to know where to start. I’ve spent hours researching and testing different holsters, and I’m here to share my top picks for the best leather holsters for your 1911 Commander.
Here’s a quick rundown of the holsters we’ll be looking at:
- Safariland 5197 Open Top Concealment Holster: Fast draw, durable, and comfortable.
- Galco Combat Master Belt Holster: Hand-molded, precise fit, and classic design.
- DeSantis Mini Scabbard Holster: Minimalist design, easy on/off, and great for concealment.
- Alien Gear Cloak Tuck 3.5 IWB Holster: Hybrid design, comfortable for all-day wear, adjustable retention.
- Craft Holsters Open Top Leather Holster: Custom-molded, high-quality leather, and durable stitching.
Top 5 Best Leather Holsters for 1911 Commander
Safariland 5197 Open Top Concealment Holster
The Safariland 5197 is designed for speed and comfort. It’s an open-top holster, allowing for a fast and smooth draw, which is crucial in high-pressure situations. The durable construction ensures your 1911 Commander stays secure, while the comfortable design makes it ideal for all-day carry.
Pros:
- ✅ Extremely fast draw.
- ✅ Very durable construction.
- ✅ Comfortable for concealed carry.
Cons:
- ❌ Retention may need adjustment for some users.
- ❌ Leather can be a bit stiff initially.
- ❌ Not ideal for open carry in all situations.
Verdict: Great for those prioritizing speed and concealment. If you need a reliable holster that allows for a quick draw, the Safariland 5197 is a solid choice.
Galco Combat Master Belt Holster
Galco is a name synonymous with quality leather holsters, and the Combat Master is no exception. This holster is hand-molded to ensure a precise fit for your 1911 Commander. Its classic design and high-quality leather make it both functional and aesthetically pleasing.
Pros:
- ✅ Excellent craftsmanship and hand-molded fit.
- ✅ High-quality leather that lasts.
- ✅ Classic and professional look.
Cons:
- ❌ Higher price point compared to other options.
- ❌ Break-in period required for optimal fit.
- ❌ May not be ideal for deep concealment.
Verdict: If you appreciate quality and are willing to invest in a holster that will last, the Galco Combat Master is an excellent choice. Its precise fit and durable construction make it a reliable option for everyday carry.
DeSantis Mini Scabbard Holster
The DeSantis Mini Scabbard is all about simplicity and ease of use. Its minimalist design makes it easy to put on and take off, and it’s perfect for those who prefer a smaller, more discreet holster. Despite its size, it provides excellent retention and keeps your 1911 Commander secure.
Pros:
- ✅ Minimalist and compact design.
- ✅ Easy to put on and take off.
- ✅ Great for concealed carry.
Cons:
- ❌ Less coverage compared to full-size holsters.
- ❌ Retention might require adjustment over time.
- ❌ May not be as comfortable for all-day wear as larger holsters.
Verdict: Ideal for those who want a simple, no-frills holster that’s easy to use. If you value convenience and concealability, the DeSantis Mini Scabbard is a great option.
Alien Gear Cloak Tuck 3.5 IWB Holster
The Alien Gear Cloak Tuck 3.5 is a hybrid holster, combining a leather backer with a molded shell for superior comfort and retention. This inside-the-waistband (IWB) holster is designed for all-day wear, with adjustable cant and retention to customize your carry experience.
Pros:
- ✅ Comfortable for all-day IWB carry.
- ✅ Adjustable cant and retention.
- ✅ Hybrid design combines leather and polymer for durability.
Cons:
- ❌ Can be bulky compared to minimalist holsters.
- ❌ Requires some adjustment to find the perfect fit.
- ❌ Not ideal for those who prefer traditional all-leather holsters.
Verdict: Great for those seeking a comfortable and adjustable IWB holster. If you need something you can wear all day without discomfort, the Alien Gear Cloak Tuck 3.5 is worth considering.
Craft Holsters Open Top Leather Holster
Craft Holsters focuses on custom-molded leather holsters that provide a perfect fit for your specific firearm. This open-top leather holster is designed for both comfort and durability, with high-quality leather and strong stitching ensuring it will last for years.
Pros:
- ✅ Custom-molded for a perfect fit.
- ✅ High-quality leather and durable stitching.
- ✅ Comfortable for everyday carry.
Cons:
- ❌ Can be a bit pricey compared to mass-produced options.
- ❌ Longer lead times due to custom manufacturing.
- ❌ Retention may require initial break-in.
Verdict: If you want a holster that’s specifically tailored to your 1911 Commander and are willing to wait for a custom product, Craft Holsters is an excellent choice. Their attention to detail and quality craftsmanship make their holsters stand out.
Buying Guide
Choosing the right leather holster for your 1911 Commander involves considering several factors. Here are some tips to help you make the best decision:
- Carry Style: Determine how you want to carry your firearm. Options include outside-the-waistband (OWB), inside-the-waistband (IWB), and shoulder holsters. Each style has its own advantages and disadvantages in terms of comfort, concealment, and accessibility.
- Retention: Consider the level of retention you need. Some holsters rely on friction, while others have adjustable retention devices. A good holster should securely hold your firearm while still allowing for a smooth and fast draw.
- Material Quality: Look for holsters made from high-quality leather. Full-grain leather is generally more durable and will last longer than cheaper alternatives. Check the stitching and hardware to ensure they are robust and well-made.
- Comfort: If you plan to carry your firearm for extended periods, comfort is crucial. Look for holsters with a comfortable backing and smooth edges to prevent chafing. Consider hybrid holsters that combine leather with other materials like nylon or Kydex for added comfort and durability.
- Concealment: If concealment is a priority, choose a holster that is designed for concealed carry. IWB holsters are generally better for concealment than OWB holsters. Look for features like adjustable cant and ride height to help you position your firearm for optimal concealment.
- Firearm Compatibility: Ensure the holster is specifically designed for the 1911 Commander. A proper fit is essential for both safety and retention. Avoid generic holsters that may not provide a secure fit.
- Price: Leather holsters can range in price from affordable to quite expensive. Set a budget and consider the value you’re getting for your money. A higher-priced holster may offer better quality, durability, and comfort, but there are also good options available at more reasonable prices.
FAQs
Q: What is the best type of leather for a holster?
A: Full-grain leather is generally considered the best for holsters due to its durability and resistance to wear and tear. It’s also more resistant to moisture and will retain its shape better over time.
Q: How do I break in a new leather holster?
A: You can break in a leather holster by wrapping your unloaded firearm in a plastic bag and inserting it into the holster. Leave it overnight to stretch the leather. Repeat as necessary until the firearm fits comfortably. You can also use a leather conditioner to soften the leather and speed up the break-in process.
Q: How do I clean and maintain my leather holster?
A: Clean your leather holster regularly with a soft cloth and a mild leather cleaner. Avoid using harsh chemicals or solvents, as they can damage the leather. Apply a leather conditioner periodically to keep the leather supple and prevent it from drying out. Store your holster in a cool, dry place when not in use.
Q: Are leather holsters better than Kydex holsters?
A: It depends on your personal preferences and needs. Leather holsters are often more comfortable and offer a classic look, while Kydex holsters are more durable, water-resistant, and offer better retention. Consider the pros and cons of each material before making a decision.
Conclusion
Choosing the best leather holster for your 1911 Commander ultimately comes down to personal preference. Consider your carry style, desired level of retention, and budget when making your decision. Each of the holsters reviewed offers unique benefits, so take the time to find the one that best suits your needs. Whether you prioritize speed, comfort, or classic design, there’s a leather holster out there that’s perfect for you.
This site contains affiliate links. As an Amazon Associate, I earn from qualifying purchases. This means if you click on a link and buy a product, we may receive a small commission at no extra cost to you.
