A good fly reel is more than just a line holder. It balances your rod, protects your line, and can make the difference between landing a trophy fish and watching it swim away. For a versatile setup, a 5wt fly reel is a popular choice, perfect for trout, panfish, and even some bass. Finding the right one can be overwhelming, so I’ve put together a list of the top performers to help you make the best choice.
Here’s a quick look at my top picks for the best 5wt fly reels:
- Orvis Battenkill Disc IV: Classic design meets modern performance.
- Redington Behemoth: Unmatched drag power at an affordable price.
- Lamson Liquid: Lightweight and durable, great for all-around use.
- Ross Animas: A smooth and reliable reel with a stunning design.
- Waterworks-Lamson Remix: Hybrid construction for the best of both worlds.
Top 5 Best 5wt Fly Reel Reviews
1. Orvis Battenkill Disc IV
The Orvis Battenkill Disc IV is a modern take on a classic reel. It features a time-tested design with a powerful sealed disc drag system. This reel combines tradition with performance, making it a reliable choice for any angler.
Pros:
- ✅ Classic design and aesthetics
- ✅ Reliable sealed disc drag
- ✅ Lightweight for balanced feel
Cons:
- ❌ May be pricier than other options
- ❌ Traditional look might not appeal to everyone
Verdict: A great choice for anglers who appreciate classic design and need a dependable reel with a smooth drag system.
2. Redington Behemoth
The Redington Behemoth lives up to its name with its oversized drag knob and impressive stopping power. This reel is designed to handle large, aggressive fish. If you’re looking for a budget-friendly reel with serious power, the Behemoth is it.
Pros:
- ✅ Powerful carbon fiber drag system
- ✅ Oversized drag knob for easy adjustments
- ✅ Affordable price point
Cons:
- ❌ Can feel heavier than other reels
- ❌ Finish may show wear and tear over time
Verdict: Ideal for anglers targeting larger fish on a budget who need a reel with a strong drag system.
3. Lamson Liquid
The Lamson Liquid is known for its lightweight design and exceptional value. It’s a fully machined reel offered at a cast price. This reel provides excellent performance without breaking the bank, making it perfect for beginners and experienced anglers alike.
Pros:
- ✅ Extremely lightweight
- ✅ Durable machined construction
- ✅ Affordable price
Cons:
- ❌ Drag system not as powerful as higher-end models
- ❌ Simpler design compared to other Lamson reels
Verdict: A fantastic all-around reel for anglers who want a lightweight, durable option at a great price.
4. Ross Animas
The Ross Animas is a beautifully designed reel with a reputation for smooth performance and reliability. It features a canvas Micarta drag system and a large arbor design for quick line retrieval. The Animas is a reel that looks as good as it performs.
Pros:
- ✅ Smooth and reliable drag system
- ✅ Large arbor design for fast line retrieval
- ✅ Attractive aesthetics
Cons:
- ❌ Higher price point
- ❌ May not be as suitable for saltwater use
Verdict: A top-tier reel for anglers who want a combination of performance, aesthetics, and reliability.
5. Waterworks-Lamson Remix
The Waterworks-Lamson Remix combines a machined aluminum frame with a cast aluminum spool. This hybrid construction balances durability with affordability. The Remix offers performance features found in higher-end Lamson reels at a more accessible price.
Pros:
- ✅ Hybrid construction for durability and affordability
- ✅ Conical drag system for smooth performance
- ✅ Modern design
Cons:
- ❌ Cast spool may not be as durable as a fully machined spool
- ❌ Mid-range price point
Verdict: A great option for anglers who want a reel with high-end features without the premium price tag.
Buying Guide
Choosing the right 5wt fly reel can seem daunting, but focusing on a few key factors will help you narrow down your options. Here’s what to consider:
- Drag System: The drag system is crucial for fighting fish, especially larger ones. Look for reels with smooth and consistent drag. Sealed drag systems are ideal for preventing dirt and water from affecting performance. Disc drag systems are generally more powerful than click-and-pawl systems.
- Reel Weight: A balanced rod and reel setup is essential for comfortable casting. Consider the weight of the reel in relation to your 5wt fly rod. A reel that’s too heavy or too light can throw off your casting stroke.
- Arbor Size: Arbor size refers to the diameter of the spool. Large arbor reels retrieve line faster than standard arbor reels, which can be a significant advantage when fighting fish.
- Material and Construction: Reels are typically made from machined aluminum, cast aluminum, or a combination of both. Machined aluminum reels are more durable and have tighter tolerances, but they’re also more expensive. Cast aluminum reels are more affordable but may not be as durable.
- Price: Fly reels range in price from under $100 to over $500. Determine your budget and look for reels that offer the best value within that range. Keep in mind that a higher price doesn’t always guarantee better performance.
- Intended Use: Consider the type of fishing you’ll be doing most often. If you’re primarily fishing for small trout in streams, a lightweight reel with a basic drag system may be sufficient. If you’re targeting larger fish in rivers or lakes, you’ll want a reel with a more powerful drag. Also, consider if you will be using the reel in saltwater, as this requires a sealed drag system.
FAQs
Q: What is a 5wt fly reel used for?
A: A 5wt fly reel is a versatile size suitable for trout, panfish, and smaller bass. It’s a popular choice for all-around freshwater fishing.
Q: What is the difference between a click-and-pawl drag and a disc drag?
A: Click-and-pawl drags are simpler and provide resistance through a spring-loaded pawl that engages with a toothed gear. Disc drags use a series of discs to create friction, offering smoother and more powerful drag performance.
Q: How do I choose the right size fly reel for my rod?
A: Match the reel size to the rod’s weight rating. A 5wt rod should be paired with a 5wt reel. Check the reel’s specifications to ensure it can hold the appropriate amount of backing and fly line.
Q: What does “arbor size” mean?
A: Arbor size refers to the diameter of the reel’s spool. Large arbor reels retrieve line faster and reduce line memory compared to standard arbor reels.
Q: How important is a sealed drag system?
A: A sealed drag system is crucial for protecting the drag mechanism from dirt, water, and debris. It’s especially important for saltwater fishing or fishing in harsh conditions.
Conclusion
Finding the perfect 5wt fly reel depends on your individual needs and preferences. Whether you prioritize classic design, unmatched drag power, or lightweight performance, there’s a reel on this list for you. Take the time to consider your fishing style and the types of fish you’ll be targeting, and you’ll be sure to find a reel that enhances your time on the water.
This site contains affiliate links. As an Amazon Associate, I earn from qualifying purchases. This means if you click on a link and buy a product, we may receive a small commission at no extra cost to you.
