Living in a state with strict gun laws can be frustrating, especially when you’re an AR-15 enthusiast. Converting your AR to a fixed magazine configuration might seem like a hassle, but it opens up possibilities for compliant ownership. I’ve spent a good amount of time researching and even tinkering with different fixed mag AR setups, so I’ve got some insights to share. This article will highlight some of the best fixed magazine AR-15 options and conversion kits available, helping you navigate the complexities of compliance while still enjoying your rifle.
Product Overview / Quick Summary:
- Troy A4 Other Carbine (Fixed Mag): Complete fixed magazine AR-15, known for reliability.
- Franklin Armory DFM AR-15: Another compliant complete rifle, good reputation.
- Cross Armory SAFE MAG 2: Drop-in fixed magazine kit, easy install.
- AR Maglock Gen 4: Popular fixed magazine conversion kit.
- Compmag AR-15 Fixed Magazine: Complete fixed magazine lower receiver.
Top 5 Best Fixed Magazine AR-15 Reviews
1. Troy A4 Other Carbine (Fixed Mag)
The Troy A4 Other Carbine is a complete fixed magazine AR-15 rifle. It’s built to be compliant right out of the box, meaning you don’t have to worry about modifications. Troy’s reputation for quality and reliability makes this a solid choice.
Pros:
- ✅ High-quality construction from a reputable manufacturer.
- ✅ Compliant right out of the box, no modifications needed.
- ✅ Troy’s dependable reputation.
Cons:
- ❌ Can be more expensive than buying a standard AR and converting it.
- ❌ Limited customization options compared to building your own.
- ❌ Some users might prefer different furniture than what’s included.
Verdict: Great for those who want a ready-to-go, compliant AR-15 without the hassle of modifications. It’s a reliable and well-built option for shooters in restricted states.
2. Franklin Armory DFM AR-15
The Franklin Armory DFM AR-15 is designed to be compliant in states with assault weapon bans. It uses a fixed magazine system, allowing you to own an AR-15 without the usual restrictions. Franklin Armory has a solid reputation in the firearms industry.
Pros:
- ✅ Factory-built compliant AR-15.
- ✅ Good reputation for quality and reliability.
- ✅ Removes the need to modify a standard AR-15.
Cons:
- ❌ May be pricier than converting an existing AR.
- ❌ Limited options for customization compared to building your own.
- ❌ Availability may vary depending on your location.
Verdict: An excellent choice for those who want a reliable, compliant AR-15 straight from the manufacturer. It’s a solid option for shooters in restricted states who value quality and dependability.
3. Cross Armory SAFE MAG 2
The Cross Armory SAFE MAG 2 is a drop-in fixed magazine conversion kit. It’s designed for easy installation, allowing you to convert your existing AR-15 to a fixed magazine configuration quickly. This kit is a popular choice for those looking for a user-friendly solution.
Pros:
- ✅ Easy to install, even for beginners.
- ✅ Relatively affordable compared to other options.
- ✅ Allows you to use your existing AR-15 lower.
Cons:
- ❌ Requires you to break the action to reload.
- ❌ May not be compatible with all AR-15 lowers.
- ❌ Some users find the reloading process slower than with standard magazines.
Verdict: A solid choice for those who want a simple and affordable way to convert their AR-15 to a fixed magazine configuration. It’s easy to install and use, making it a good option for most AR owners.
4. AR Maglock Gen 4
The AR Maglock Gen 4 is a popular fixed magazine conversion kit known for its robust design. It allows you to quickly release the magazine for reloading by disengaging the bolt catch. This kit is designed for durability and ease of use.
Pros:
- ✅ Durable and reliable design.
- ✅ Allows for relatively quick magazine changes.
- ✅ Compatible with most AR-15 platforms.
Cons:
- ❌ Requires some mechanical skill to install properly.
- ❌ Can be more expensive than other fixed magazine solutions.
- ❌ Some users find the system a bit clunky at first.
Verdict: A good option for those who want a durable and reliable fixed magazine system with a relatively quick reloading process. It’s a bit more involved to install, but the performance is worth it.
5. Compmag AR-15 Fixed Magazine
The Compmag AR-15 Fixed Magazine is a complete lower receiver with a pre-installed fixed magazine. It offers a convenient way to build a compliant AR-15 without needing to modify an existing lower. The Compmag system is known for its ease of use and reliability.
Pros:
- ✅ Complete lower receiver, ready to build upon.
- ✅ Easy to use and reliable system.
- ✅ Eliminates the need to modify an existing lower.
Cons:
- ❌ More expensive than buying just a conversion kit.
- ❌ Requires you to purchase a complete lower receiver.
- ❌ Limited customization options compared to building from scratch.
Verdict: Ideal for those who want a hassle-free way to build a compliant AR-15. The Compmag lower receiver offers a simple and reliable solution for shooters in restricted states.
Buying Guide
Choosing the right fixed magazine AR-15 or conversion kit can be tricky, so here are some things to consider:
- Compliance: Always double-check your local and state laws to ensure your chosen configuration is compliant. Laws can change, so stay updated.
- Ease of Installation: If you’re not mechanically inclined, opt for a drop-in kit or a complete rifle. Some kits require more technical skills than others.
- Reliability: Research the brand and read reviews to ensure the system is reliable. A malfunction at the range is frustrating; a malfunction in a critical situation is dangerous.
- Reloading Speed: Fixed magazine systems inherently slow down reloading. Consider how important speed is to you and choose a system that balances compliance with efficiency.
- Budget: Complete rifles are generally more expensive than conversion kits. Decide how much you’re willing to spend and find the best option within your budget.
- Compatibility: Ensure any conversion kit you choose is compatible with your existing AR-15. Not all lowers are created equal.
FAQs
Q: What is a fixed magazine AR-15?
A fixed magazine AR-15 is a rifle modified so the magazine cannot be detached without disassembling the action. This is often done to comply with state laws that restrict detachable magazines.
Q: Is a fixed magazine AR-15 legal in California?
Yes, a fixed magazine AR-15 can be legal in California if it meets specific requirements. These requirements can change, so always consult the latest California Department of Justice regulations.
Q: How do you reload a fixed magazine AR-15?
Reloading typically involves breaking the action open, often by using a tool or your finger to depress the magazine release while manipulating the bolt catch. The exact method varies depending on the specific fixed magazine system used.
Q: Can I convert my existing AR-15 to a fixed magazine?
Yes, you can convert an existing AR-15 using a variety of fixed magazine conversion kits. Just make sure to follow the instructions carefully and ensure the conversion is compliant with your local laws.
Q: Are fixed magazine AR-15s less reliable than standard AR-15s?
Not necessarily. The reliability of a fixed magazine AR-15 depends on the quality of the conversion kit and the installation. A well-made and properly installed kit should not significantly impact the rifle’s reliability.
Conclusion
Navigating the world of fixed magazine AR-15s can feel overwhelming, but it doesn’t have to be. Whether you opt for a complete fixed magazine rifle like the Troy A4 or Franklin Armory DFM, or choose to convert your existing AR with a kit like the Cross Armory SAFE MAG 2, AR Maglock Gen 4, or Compmag, the key is to prioritize compliance, reliability, and ease of use. Do your research, understand your local laws, and choose the option that best fits your needs. With the right setup, you can enjoy your AR-15 while staying within the bounds of the law.
This site contains affiliate links. As an Amazon Associate, I earn from qualifying purchases. This means if you click on a link and buy a product, we may receive a small commission at no extra cost to you.
