Finding the right throw pillow inserts can be surprisingly tricky. You want pillows that look plump and inviting, not sad and saggy. I’ve tried so many over the years, some were lumpy, others too flat, and a few just plain weird. So, I’ve rounded up the best pillow inserts I’ve found to help you avoid those decorating disasters and achieve that perfect, cozy look.
Here’s a quick look at my top picks:
- Best Overall: Pillowflex Down Alternative Pillow Insert
- Best Budget: Foamily Premium Hypoallergenic Stuffer Pillow Insert
- Best Down Feather: Bluewish Premium White Down Feather Pillow Insert
- Best for Outdoor Use: Arlee Home Fashions Pillow Form Insert
- Best Square Shape Retention: Elivo Home Premium Pillow Insert
Top 5 Best Pillow Inserts for Throw Pillows
1. Pillowflex Down Alternative Pillow Insert
The Pillowflex Down Alternative Pillow Insert is a fantastic all-around choice for anyone seeking a plush and supportive insert. It’s made with a hypoallergenic microfiber fill that mimics the softness of down, without the allergens. I’ve used these in my living room for years, and they hold their shape beautifully.
Pros:
- ✅ Hypoallergenic, making it great for sensitive individuals.
- ✅ Soft and comfortable, mimicking the feel of down.
- ✅ Holds its shape well, providing good support.
Cons:
- ❌ Can be a bit pricier than other down alternative options.
- ❌ Some users find the fill shifts slightly over time.
- ❌ Not ideal if you prefer a very firm pillow.
Verdict: A great option for those who want the feel of down without the allergens or ethical concerns. It’s a worthwhile investment for long-lasting comfort and support.
2. Foamily Premium Hypoallergenic Stuffer Pillow Insert
If you’re looking for an affordable option that doesn’t compromise on quality, the Foamily Premium Hypoallergenic Stuffer Pillow Insert is a great pick. These are made with a blend of polyester fibers, making them both soft and durable. I’ve used these for decorative pillows in guest rooms, and they’ve held up nicely.
Pros:
- ✅ Very budget-friendly, allowing you to outfit many pillows without breaking the bank.
- ✅ Hypoallergenic, suitable for people with allergies.
- ✅ Maintains its shape reasonably well.
Cons:
- ❌ Not as plush or luxurious as down or higher-end down alternatives.
- ❌ Might require extra fluffing to maintain optimal shape.
- ❌ Some users find the fill to be slightly lumpy.
Verdict: Excellent for those on a budget or needing a large number of inserts. They offer a good balance of comfort and affordability.
3. Bluewish Premium White Down Feather Pillow Insert
For those who truly love the luxurious feel of down, the Bluewish Premium White Down Feather Pillow Insert is an excellent choice. These inserts are filled with a blend of white down and feathers, providing that classic sink-in comfort. They’re what I use in my own bedroom, and I love how they look and feel.
Pros:
- ✅ Offers the ultimate in softness and comfort.
- ✅ Molds to your body, providing excellent support.
- ✅ Long-lasting and durable with proper care.
Cons:
- ❌ Can be more expensive than down alternative options.
- ❌ May require regular fluffing to maintain loft.
- ❌ Not suitable for individuals with down allergies.
Verdict: If you appreciate the feel of real down, these inserts are a worthwhile splurge. Just be mindful of potential allergies and the need for proper maintenance.
4. Arlee Home Fashions Pillow Form Insert
The Arlee Home Fashions Pillow Form Insert is specifically designed for outdoor use, making it a great option for patio furniture or poolside décor. These are made with a water-resistant fabric and a polyester fiberfill that resists mildew. I’ve used these on my porch, and they’ve survived several unexpected rainstorms.
Pros:
- ✅ Water-resistant, making them ideal for outdoor use.
- ✅ Mildew-resistant, preventing mold growth in humid environments.
- ✅ Holds its shape well, even with frequent use.
Cons:
- ❌ Not as soft or plush as indoor-specific inserts.
- ❌ Limited size options compared to other brands.
- ❌ May feel slightly stiff compared to down or down alternative.
Verdict: A must-have for anyone looking to add comfort and style to their outdoor spaces. Their water-resistant properties make them a practical and durable choice.
5. Elivo Home Premium Pillow Insert
If you want your square throw pillows to actually look square, the Elivo Home Premium Pillow Insert is a fantastic choice. These inserts are overstuffed with a high-quality polyester fill that helps them maintain their shape. I’ve used these in my formal living room, and they always look perfectly plump and polished.
Pros:
- ✅ Excellent shape retention, ensuring your pillows look full and square.
- ✅ High-quality fill provides good support and comfort.
- ✅ Available in a wide range of sizes.
Cons:
- ❌ Can be slightly firmer than other down alternative options.
- ❌ May require some initial fluffing to achieve optimal shape.
- ❌ Slightly higher price point compared to basic polyester inserts.
Verdict: Ideal for those who prioritize shape and appearance. These inserts provide a polished and sophisticated look for any space.
Buying Guide
Choosing the right pillow insert can feel overwhelming, but here are a few things to consider:
- Size: Always choose an insert that is 1-2 inches larger than your pillow cover. This will ensure a plump, full look. For example, if you have an 18×18 inch pillow cover, opt for a 20×20 inch insert.
- Fill Material: Down, down alternative, and polyester are the most common options. Down is the most luxurious but also the most expensive and allergenic. Down alternative offers a similar feel without the allergens. Polyester is the most affordable but can sometimes be lumpy.
- Shape: Square, rectangular, and round pillow inserts are available. Choose the shape that best complements your pillow cover and décor.
- Firmness: Consider how you plan to use the pillows. Firmer inserts are better for support, while softer inserts are more comfortable for lounging.
- Intended Use: Will these be used indoors or outdoors? Choose water-resistant and mildew-resistant options for outdoor use.
FAQs
Q: How do I choose the right size pillow insert?
A: Select an insert that’s 1-2 inches larger than your pillow cover. This ensures a full, plump appearance.
Q: What’s the difference between down and down alternative?
A: Down is a natural fill that’s incredibly soft and luxurious. Down alternative mimics the feel of down but is hypoallergenic and often more affordable.
Q: How often should I replace my pillow inserts?
A: It depends on the quality of the insert and how frequently it’s used. Generally, you should replace them every 1-2 years, or when they start to lose their shape and support.
Q: Can I wash my pillow inserts?
A: Always check the care label. Some inserts are machine washable, while others require spot cleaning or professional laundering.
Q: How do I fluff my pillow inserts?
A: For down and down alternative inserts, you can fluff them by hand or put them in the dryer on a low setting with a few tennis balls. For polyester inserts, you may need to manually redistribute the fill.
Conclusion
Finding the perfect pillow inserts can truly transform the look and feel of your home. Whether you prioritize luxury, affordability, or durability, there’s an insert out there to meet your needs. I hope this guide has helped you narrow down your options and find the perfect pillows to create a cozy and inviting space.
This site contains affiliate links. As an Amazon Associate, I earn from qualifying purchases. This means if you click on a link and buy a product, we may receive a small commission at no extra cost to you.
