Few firearms capture the spirit of the Wild West quite like the Schofield revolver. It’s a piece of history, a symbol of lawmen and outlaws, and a beautifully designed firearm. Finding an original in good condition is tough (and expensive!), so a good reproduction is the next best thing. Fortunately, there are some great options out there that capture the look and feel of the original.
This article will walk you through the best Schofield revolver reproductions currently available. We’ll cover what makes them stand out, their pros and cons, and who they’re best suited for. I’ll also give you some pointers on what to look for when choosing one for yourself.
Product Overview / Quick Summary
- Uberti 1873 Schofield Top Break Revolver: Best overall, closest to original specs.
- Taylor’s & Co. 1875 Schofield Outlaw: Great for those wanting a unique, customized look.
- Cimarron Firearms Schofield Model 3: Excellent fit and finish, smooth action.
- EMF Hartford Schofield No. 3: Budget-friendly option, decent quality for the price.
- Navy Arms Schofield Revolver: Reliable and durable, good for Cowboy Action Shooting.
Top 5 Best Schofield Revolver Reproduction
1. Uberti 1873 Schofield Top Break Revolver
The Uberti 1873 Schofield is widely considered the best overall reproduction. It’s made by a company known for its high-quality replicas, and this one is no exception. Uberti really nails the details, making it as close to the original as you can get with a reproduction.
Pros:
- ✅ Very accurate reproduction of the original 1873 Schofield.
- ✅ High-quality materials and construction.
- ✅ Smooth action and reliable performance.
Cons:
- ❌ Can be a bit pricey compared to other reproductions.
- ❌ Some users report minor cosmetic imperfections.
- ❌ Grips may need slight fitting for some users.
Verdict: If you’re looking for the most authentic Schofield reproduction and are willing to pay a bit more, the Uberti 1873 is the way to go. It’s a beautiful and well-made revolver that you’ll be proud to own.
2. Taylor’s & Co. 1875 Schofield Outlaw
Taylor’s & Co. offers a few variations of the Schofield, but the “Outlaw” model is particularly interesting. It has a unique, customized look that sets it apart from other reproductions. If you want something a little different, this is a great option.
Pros:
- ✅ Unique “Outlaw” design with custom finishes.
- ✅ Good quality construction and reliable performance.
- ✅ Available in multiple calibers (e.g., .45 Colt, .38 Special).
Cons:
- ❌ The “Outlaw” look might not appeal to purists.
- ❌ Custom finishes can add to the overall cost.
- ❌ May require some break-in period for optimal smoothness.
Verdict: The Taylor’s & Co. 1875 Schofield Outlaw is perfect for those who want a Schofield reproduction with a unique, personalized touch. It’s a reliable and eye-catching revolver.
3. Cimarron Firearms Schofield Model 3
Cimarron Firearms is known for its attention to detail and high-quality reproductions, and their Schofield Model 3 is no exception. This revolver boasts excellent fit and finish, making it a pleasure to handle and shoot. I’ve always been impressed by the smoothness of their actions.
Pros:
- ✅ Excellent fit and finish.
- ✅ Smooth action right out of the box.
- ✅ High level of historical accuracy.
Cons:
- ❌ Can be difficult to find in stock.
- ❌ Price point is higher than some other options.
- ❌ Some users have reported minor issues with the rear sight.
Verdict: If you appreciate fine craftsmanship and a smooth-shooting revolver, the Cimarron Firearms Schofield Model 3 is an excellent choice. It’s a beautiful and well-made reproduction that will impress even the most discerning shooter.
4. EMF Hartford Schofield No. 3
If you’re on a budget but still want a Schofield reproduction, the EMF Hartford Schofield No. 3 is worth considering. It’s a more affordable option that still offers decent quality and performance. It’s a good starting point if you’re new to these types of revolvers.
Pros:
- ✅ Most affordable option on the list.
- ✅ Decent quality for the price.
- ✅ Good for beginners or casual shooters.
Cons:
- ❌ Fit and finish may not be as refined as higher-end models.
- ❌ Action may require some tuning for optimal smoothness.
- ❌ May not be as historically accurate as other reproductions.
Verdict: The EMF Hartford Schofield No. 3 is a great option for those who want a Schofield reproduction without breaking the bank. It’s a reliable and affordable revolver that’s perfect for casual shooting or collecting.
5. Navy Arms Schofield Revolver
Navy Arms has been importing and selling reproduction firearms for decades, and their Schofield Revolver is a solid and reliable option. It’s known for its durability and is a popular choice for Cowboy Action Shooting. I’ve seen these stand up to a lot of use.
Pros:
- ✅ Durable and reliable construction.
- ✅ Good for Cowboy Action Shooting.
- ✅ Readily available and easy to find.
Cons:
- ❌ May not be as historically accurate as some other models.
- ❌ Fit and finish can be inconsistent.
- ❌ Action may require some tuning for competitive shooting.
Verdict: The Navy Arms Schofield Revolver is a solid and dependable choice for those who need a durable revolver for Cowboy Action Shooting or general use. It’s a workhorse that will stand up to a lot of abuse.
Buying Guide
Choosing the right Schofield revolver reproduction can be tricky, but here are some things to keep in mind:
- Accuracy: How closely does the reproduction match the original Schofield revolver in terms of design, dimensions, and markings? If historical accuracy is important to you, look for models that are known for their attention to detail.
- Quality: Check the quality of the materials and construction. Look for revolvers made from high-quality steel with a well-fitted action. Read reviews to see what other users have to say about the revolver’s durability and reliability.
- Caliber: Schofield revolvers were originally chambered in .45 Schofield, but reproductions are often available in other calibers like .45 Colt and .38 Special. Consider which caliber is best for your needs in terms of availability, cost, and recoil.
- Intended Use: Are you planning to use the revolver for collecting, target shooting, Cowboy Action Shooting, or something else? Different models may be better suited for different purposes. For example, a Cowboy Action Shooting revolver should be durable and reliable, while a collector’s piece should be as historically accurate as possible.
- Budget: Schofield revolver reproductions can range in price from a few hundred dollars to over a thousand. Determine your budget before you start shopping and stick to it. Keep in mind that you often get what you pay for, so it may be worth spending a bit more for a higher-quality revolver.
FAQs
Q: What’s the difference between a Schofield and a Colt Single Action Army?
A: The Schofield is a top-break revolver, meaning it opens at the top for faster reloading. The Colt SAA, on the other hand, has a loading gate on the side and requires manually ejecting each cartridge. The Schofield was favored by some for its faster reloading capability.
Q: What caliber should I choose for my Schofield reproduction?
A: The original Schofield was chambered in .45 Schofield. However, .45 Colt and .38 Special are also common in reproductions. .45 Colt is a powerful round with a lot of historical appeal, while .38 Special is more affordable and has less recoil.
Q: Are Schofield reproductions legal to own?
A: In most places, yes. Because they are reproductions of antique firearms, they are often not subject to the same restrictions as modern firearms. However, it’s always best to check your local laws and regulations to be sure.
Q: Do I need to do any maintenance on my Schofield reproduction?
A: Yes, like any firearm, a Schofield reproduction requires regular cleaning and lubrication to keep it in good working order. Consult the owner’s manual for specific instructions.
Conclusion
Finding the perfect Schofield revolver reproduction is all about knowing what you want and what you’re willing to spend. Whether you’re a history buff, a Cowboy Action Shooter, or just someone who appreciates a well-made firearm, there’s a Schofield reproduction out there for you. I hope this guide has helped you narrow down your choices and find the perfect addition to your collection. Happy shooting!
This site contains affiliate links. As an Amazon Associate, I earn from qualifying purchases. This means if you click on a link and buy a product, we may receive a small commission at no extra cost to you.
